Showing posts with label 2K Games. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2K Games. Show all posts

Sunday, July 21, 2013

Time in a Bottle

 I'll be back! (and other famous last words)

General Douglas MacArthur makes good on his promise to return to the Philippines during WWII

I return to my orphaned blog nearly two years to the day since my last post. At the time I had big plans for content and updates, mainly because of my own personal interests with regards to gaming and tech and specifically because I had a lot of time on my hands. I had always been a super-consumer of tech and gaming news, and I felt that I also had something positive I could contribute back to the the community in this regard.

I launched the blog with the intention that it would be my little corner of the web where I could occasionally climb up on my soapbox and talk about things that mattered to me and may also be of interest to a wider audience in general. I would post what I felt were newsworthy items, provide some analysis or commentary, and talk about games and tech. Although I only managed to squeak past a dozen posts, what is present is a good representation of the vision I had for my blog.

Then, REAL LIFE (tm) caught up with me and, well, we know the old saying about the best laid plans...

 

A blast from the past


Last night I had spent the better part of an hour revisiting my original posts and discovered that they made for a good time capsule. The posts covered a very short period of time, and they had captured what in my mind were newsworthy or discussion worthy items of the period in question. The intervening two years neatly encapsulated these posts and allowed me to view them with 20/20 hindsight.

In the quickly changing technology and gaming landscape, industry observers and pundits  alike have a hard time making predictions based on current trends with any amount of accuracy even months out, much less for a period of years. What I found most interesting about some of my posts, was how prophetic some of them actually turned out to be.

The next next-gen


On the matter of next-gen hardware, I think I got most of it right - much to my surprise. Back in 2011, much of the gaming press was still casting about trying to figure out when the next, next-gen was going to arrive. Estimates ranged from holiday 2012 all the way up to 2017. In my commentary and analysis of Nintendo's Wii-U, I predicted that both Microsoft's and Sony's next-gen consoles would be out probably by 2013 and latest by 2014.
 
I was also spot on regarding the Wii-U's (mis)fortunes to date. Nintendo's Wii-U sales have been lackluster and it suffers from the same issues facing the previous generation Wii - lack of content from third parties and first party developers - which I predicted would be a problem for Nintendo. And now that Microsoft and Sony are launching real next-gen hardware with lots of content during their launch windows this holiday season, I see the Nintendo ship slowly sinking under its own weight.

It's all about the games


I started this blog with an initial post on the XCOM reboot by 2K Games. XCOM is a series very near and dear to my heart and to the hearts of many gamers now in their 30's and 40's. It was a simple game to grasp, but like any good game it was difficult to master. There was a lot of concern with the direction that 2K was taking this franchise and I put in my two cents worth on what I thought 2K needed to do to to make things right with the XCOM fanbase. 

At the time, there was a lot of concern that 2K was going to make a shooter with the XCOM license but not provide the game with the strategic and role-playing elements that made the original XCOM series a critical success. In the intervening two years, 2K has reworked the original concept into The Bureau: XCOM Declassified, due out next month.


The Evolution of The Bureau: XCOM Declassified courtesy IGN

Recent trailers during and after E3 show a very polished third person perspective shooter, but with strategic and role-play elements necessary for a proper XCOM branded game. While the focus has changed from being the overall commander to that of a battlefield commander, the inclusion of real-time shooter mechanics create a more frenetic and fast paced game with a sense of real urgency. If anything, the real-time battles are even more visceral and immediate.

We even got an updated turn-based XCOM from Firaxis which came out of left field to become one of the best games of 2012. The first time I heard of this development was well into 2012 and long after I had stopped blogging; but just the same, I'm very glad Firaxis was able to create a modern XCOM game for the current generation of gamers, many of whom knew nothing about this seminal franchise.

Firaxis' XCOM Enemy Unknown gameplay, a modern update to a seminal classic

Looking back, I'm really quite amazed at how relevant some of my posts still are, two years after they were made.



Friday, June 17, 2011

Duke Nukem Forever: Press Censorship and the View from Above

Duke Nukem Forever: Probably the last outing for this iconic gaming franchise. RIP 2011.

For the past few days since the release of Duke Nukem Forever, the tweetosphere and blogosphere has literally been ablaze with postings from 2K Games/Redner Group/Gearbox Software and independent gaming media outlets; with both sides crying foul. In the process, what has been revealed of the dark underbelly of the gaming industry has given me pause to wonder exactly how much we can really trust the published reviews we use to make our purchasing decisions.

Caught in the Act: The post that started the whole ball rolling, courtesy of Ars Technica.

At issue are the poor media reviews for Duke Nukem Forever. DNF is certainly not the first game to ever get a poor review. This spot is also usually reserved for most movie tie-in games. However the level of vitriol leveled at Duke Nukem is rarely seen from the gaming press, more so that it has been unanimous across the board. In fact, the level of "venom," as The Redner Group puts it, was so great, they took the unusual step of publicly threatening to blacklist offending media outlets.

Admittedly, the level of hate for this game was pretty high. Just going by current Metacritic scores for DNF doesn't give the full picture of the reaction by gaming media. You'd have to read a few reviews to fully appreciate this. I'll get to the whys in a bit, but if I were to sum it up, I would say that everyone probably really wanted DNF to be good. While I believe expectations were kept realistically in check, everyone was pulling for the Duke and hoped he'd come through in classic underdog style. Unfortunately, DNF did surprise everyone and turned out far worse than anyone could have imagined.

To the dismay of the Duke Nukem fanbase, the classic mechanics of exploration and item collection along with rapidfire acton featured in past games were gone. Also, the humor in past Duke Nukem games were juvenile and irreverent, but never bigoted or offensive. Unfortunately, Duke Nukem Forever became an on-the-rails, corridor shooter  sandwiched between tasteless, in-game cinematic sequences. The game was dumbed down and the humor reached for the lowest common denominator. Many frankly found the game to be offensive and politically incorrect in all the wrong ways. This critical miscalculation on the part of Gearbox in terms of the tone of the game and the lowbrow humor was the final nail in the coffin.

A decade ago, these same reviewers might possibly have just laughed all of this off. But now among the target demographic, most are pushing their 40s, married with kids and are more politically correct. It's often said, "Timing is everything," and Duke Nukem Forever missed that boat 10 years ago. The lesson to be learned from this is that people's memories are sacred. Duke Nukem Forever is nothing like the classic games from the beloved franchise. Instead of reminding everyone again why they loved Duke Nukem, DNF instead reminded them of everything that the game was not.

Keep in mind DNF was a game that spent most of its 13 year development cycle in intensive care. Over the years, it got ported through several engines and eventually burned through nearly a half-dozen development teams in the process. The game was scrapped and restarted so many times the design document - if it exists - probably looked like Humpty Dumpty on a bad egg day. On the face of it, chances were pretty good the game had already lost its way long ago, certainly well before 2K Games and Gearbox got involved.

2K Games and Gearbox were probably not well prepared for the reception that DNF got. Granted, a lot of money got burned up in the development and marketing for this game but that sort of risk goes hand in hand with the potential rewards of a runaway hit for any game. Instead of taking the criticisms to heart and maybe learning something about themselves and their gaming audience, 2K Games and The Redner Group went on the offensive to defend the undefendable. In so doing, they very publicly threatened the use of blacklists against reviewers and review sites for future titles.

Publishers have historically taken a carrot and stick approach to gaming media. They reward journalists by using money to pay for them to travel, stay in nice hotels and get some nice meals as part of the process of reviewing games. Publishers also provide lots of nice free gifts. On the flip side of the coin, they use blacklists to let journalists know when they aren't happy with a review. This stuff goes on all the time, but nobody talks about it publicly. Let's just call this what it is - it is bribery and censorship plain and simple.

I'd like to think that most journalists and gaming sites have the integrity not to be swayed by these machinations.  But just as there are always those that value integrity above all else, there are also those that value the perks associated with being in the good graces of the publishers. As consumers, we have to make sure that the sites we follow are really on the up and up. Metacritic (www.metacritic.com) is a great aggregator of review information and is a good measuring stick to help us in that regard.

As gamers, we spend good money to indulge in our favorite pastime. We want to know what games are good and worth buying; and we need reliable and impartial reviews to make our purchasing decisions. Conversely, developers and publishers that make good games deserve to make money from their efforts, and those that create crap should face the consequences when consumers vote with their wallets.

Publishers and the media alike should think long and hard about the long term ramifications of the carrot and stick approach to business as usual.  Honest and impartial media helps everyone and will help the industry grow. It is the mechanism by which the wheat is separated from the chaff and helps to inspire consumer confidence. And in the long term, it will create a more healthy and vibrant gaming industry. That's a win-win in my book.

Friday, June 10, 2011

Gaming at a Crossroads

Before and After: The original X-Com (Top) and the series reboot by 2K Games (Bottom)

Welcome!

It is perhaps appropriate that my inaugural blogpost would be about X-Com which has been in the news over the past year leading up to E3. X-Com is a game franchise that has spanned nearly two decades and is home to a rabid fanbase of oldskool strategy gaming purists. Admittedly, this is probably the game that singlehandely turned me into the gamer I am today. I couldn't even begin to estimate how many hours of my life were lost to fighting aliens and saving the planet. For all the younger gamers that have no idea what I'm talking about, a bit of history is necessary.

In the Beginning

The original X-Com was a series of games made by Mythos Games/Microprose in the early 1990's. These were DOS games which required you to know your way around a command line well before Windows and point and click mouse interfaces became common. The first X-Com game occupied less than 5MB of diskspace - impossibly small by today's game standards, and came on 1.44MB 3.5" floppies.

Despite the miniscule size, X-Com was a very ambitious game for its time. It perfectly melded tabletop style wargaming with bits of resource management and RPG elements. The premise of the game was that extraterrestrials were visiting Earth for conquest. The various Earth governments banded together to form X-Com, a force specifically tasked to interdict and destroy the alien threat. Success meant increased funding for X-Com while failure meant alien subversion of various areas/governments and decreased funding.

During a typical game, you spent your time recruiting soldiers, scientists and engineers. Soldiers were used in later turn-based battles, while scientists and engineers were used to research new technologies and then putting them into production. Bases needed to be built across the world and managed in order to detect and battle alien incursions. Money was the central limiting factor which forced you to balance upgrades and expansion. The tech tree in the X-Com series were always huge and were divided between weapons, craft, power, technology and alien lifeforms.

Isometric, turn-based combat (Top) Information on Sectoid Autopsy in UFOPaedia (Bottom)

The game featured elements of RPG style leveling of troops, weapons and structures, and turn-based battles required proper squad level tactics to successfully complete. Proper management of resources were required for continual progression and eventual success. It was a deceptively simple gaming formula, and yet was a difficult game to master. The addictive gameplay was like getting hooked on virtual crack. The series spawned many sequels with the latest being the series reboot by 2K Games. For more detailed info, here's the X-Com Wiki link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-COM.

Fast Forward

Over the past year, a series reboot was announced by 2K Games, which was originally greeted with cheers by the loyal fanbase. However as more details leaked over the web culminating at this year's E3, fanbase emotions have run the spectrum from consternation to fear and now, outright anger. Many oldtimers feel that using shooter mechanics ruins the more cerebral combat of games past. To a certain extent, I have to agree with this argument.

The X-Com series has always played more like tabletop wargames rather than shooters. Success in battle hinged on using the the right troops and weapons with the right capabilities and stats. Combat resolution, while affected by chance, came down to successfully making a die roll. The new X-Com by 2K Games is proposing to change that mechanic to emphasize twitch reflexes.

However it can also be argued that this change is more evolutionary than revolutionary in nature. Tabletop wargames were the direct progenitors of the first computerized, turn-based strategy games. Over time, turn-based games like X-Com evolved into real-time strategy games such as Starcraft or Command & Conquer which required faster reflexes.

In an industry dominated by shooters, it certainly makes financial sense for developers to take that twitch factor to the next level by bringing a first person or third-person perspective to the X-Com franchise. We've seen various examples of RPGs such as The Elder Scrolls: Obilivion, Fallout 3 and the Mass Effect series using first or third person mechanics with all the stat-tracking and die rolls happening invisibly in the background. Done well, an RPG doesn't necessarily need to be a number-crunching exercise and can still provide that sense of progression and accomplishment with a more visceral and direct presentation.

The Crossroads
  
The real, underlying issue here though isn't the choice of gameplay style or presentation. It has more to do with the financial incentives involved with making a game. Games on modern consoles can cost anywhere from 10 to 20 million dollars to develop. Triple AAA titles, along with their expanded staffing requiremens and advertising budgets cost even more. Over the last several years, independent developers and publishers maximized their financial returns by supporting multiple gaming platforms. Recently, however, thanks largely to Nintendo's uber-successful Wii, an opinion has also formed that making games simpler and more accessible to a casual audience helps to create larger overall demand and sell-through. Herein lies the danger, one that is fully appreciated by the X-Com fanbase.

2K Games has chosen to update the X-Com reboot by making it more like a shooter, and the reasons for that are rather self-explanatory. The more cynical among us might even see this as a pure money grab by creating a shooter and exploiting the X-Com name. It isn't trivial to create a good RPG wrapped in shooter mechanics. In fact, it can be argued that in the worst case scenario, the whole X-Com experience could be severely dumbed down to the point that it becomes literally a brainless point and shoot twitch-fest.

It is a given that developers and publishers need to make money for the gaming industry to continue to thrive and grow. However, what 2K Games needs to keep in mind is that X-Com is a well loved franchise with a lot of history behind it. They need to respect and pay homage to the bits that made the X-Com series special to its fanbase while they update the gameplay for the 21st century. Is it possible to make a RPG-esque, strategic shooter? Absolutely - and many examples exist. So it is incumbent upon 2K Games to do the right thing in its revival of the X-Com brand. They should create an intelligent, action oriented RPG, keeping the resource management, research and tech-tree elements intact. Here's to hoping that 2K Games does this right and helps to revive a classic franchise.